Bundeskartellamt hosts webinar for competition authorities in Africa

An enforcement era is beginning in Africa. As competition authorities gather data on market structures, outcomes, and firm behaviour, they are beginning to use their enforcement powers to tackle market concentration. For enforcement, specific tools, such as questionnaires, are used to request information. Yet, to be effective, the design of these tools must be carefully considered as they can have a determinant role in assessing theories of harm.
To provide guidance to competition authorities in Africa, the Bundeskartellamt organized a webinar which brought together nearly 80 participants representing nine regional and national authorities. Dr Christoph Wigger, Deputy Head of the Chief Economist team, provided an insightful presentation on the role of economics in competition law and best practices in economic investigations, with a focus on the design of questionnaires.
How are questionnaires used in investigations?
Questionnaires are one of the major investigation tools used by competition authorities to gain essential data on markets and their participants. They help competition regulators make assessments and determine whether the theory of harm is substantiated. However, the design of the questionnaire will determine the quality of the responses received as well as the strength of the evidence that can be used to build a case (probative force).
At the Bundeskartellamt, the Chief Economist Team provides support to the responsible decision division in the development of the questionnaire and the analysis of the responses received. For the Chief Economist Team, the design of the questionnaire must focus on how to choose questions and then how to design and phrase the questions.
How to choose questions
When choosing a question, it is important they align with the theory of harm to help determine the specific information requirements and help prioritize which questions are key, and which are secondary. Questions should be directly related to the investigation and should not be superfluous as the effort required to provide the responses should be considered. Consideration should also be given to the follow up analysis that will be necessary when evaluating each response. Finally, when phrasing the questions, closed questions are preferable as they facilitate quantitative analysis. However, successful closed questions will typically require a knowledge of all possible answers a well as some form of assessment scale.
Designing and phrasing questions
When designing and phrasing questions, it is important to ask precise and easy to understand questions, without using technical jargon or multiple asks within the same question. If necessary, timeframes and scales should be clearly defined. Questions should also elicit clear responses. If using response categories, then responses should be specific and symmetric.
Questions should avoid implicit assumptions as well as biases that steer responses through, for example, the order of questions or suggestive questions. To avoid redundancies, it is important not to ask for the same type of information in multiple questions as this can lead to data inconsistencies. Finally, when collecting numerical data, it is preferable to gather absolute rather than relative numbers if possible and to only request as many data points as needed rather than what is possible.
Building a conversation
The presentation by the Deputy Head of the Chief Economist Team was followed by a lively discussion on further best practices on the design of questionnaires. This webinar hosted by the Bundeskartellamt offered an opportunity for African regulators to learn from the experiences in Germany as they begin their own enforcement journey. It is hoped that many more such webinars will follow.



